3UHSDULQJWKHIXUQLWXUH
5IFTVSSPVOEJOHLJUDIFOVOJUNVTUCFIFBUSFTJTUBOUUPBUMFBTU
p$ 5IF TUBCJMJUZ PG UIF VOJU NVTU CF NBJOUBJOFE BGUFS QSPEVDJOH
UIFDVUPVU
1SPEVDFUIFDVUPVUGPSPOFPSTFWFSBM7BSJPBQQMJBODFT1SPDFFE
BTTIPXOJOUIFJOTUBMMBUJPOTLFUDI5IFBOHMFCFUXFFOUIFDVU
TVSGBDFBOEUIFXPSLUPQNVTUCFp
"GUFSQSPEVDJOHUIFDVUPVUSFNPWFUIFTIBWJOHT4FBMUIFDVU
TVSGBDFTUPNBLFUIFNIFBUSFTJTUBOU
0CTFSWFBNJOJNVNDMFBSBODFCFUXFFOUIFBQQMJBODFIPVTJOH
BOEQBSUTPGUIFVOJUPG NN
1SPUFDUJPOBHBJOTUBDDJEFOUBMDPOUBDUGSPNCFMPXNVTUCF
HVBSBOUFFE BGUFS JOTUBMMBUJPO *G UIF VOEFSTJEF PG UIF BQQMJBODF DBO
CFUPVDIFEBGUFSJOTUBMMBUJPOBOJOUFSNFEJBUFTIFMGNVTUCFGJUUFE
UIBUDBOPOMZCFSFNPWFEVTJOHBUPPM0CTFSWFBNJOJNVN
DMFBSBODFCFUXFFOUIFBQQMJBODFBOEUIFTIFMGPG NN
:KHQILWWLQJVHYHUDO9DULRDSSOLDQFHV BMMPXGPSUIFBEEJUJPOBM
TQBDFSFRVJSFEGPSUIFDPOOFDUJOHTUSJQ77 "QQMJBODFTDBO
BMTPCFGJUUFEJOJOEJWJEVBMSFDFTTFTJGBNJOJNVNDMFBSBODFPG
NNCFUXFFOUIFBQQMJBODFTJTPCTFSWFE
(OHFWULFDOFRQQHFWLRQ
#FGPSF DPOOFDUJOH UIF BQQMJBODF DIFDL UIF IPVTFIPME JOTUBMMBUJPO
&OTVSFUIBUUIFSFJTTVGGJDJFOUGVTFQSPUFDUJPOGPSUIFIPVTFIPME
JOTUBMMBUJPO5IFWPMUBHFBOEGSFRVFODZPGUIFBQQMJBODFNVTU
NBUDIUIFFMFDUSJDBMJOTUBMMBUJPO TFFSBUJOHQMBUF
5IFBQQMJBODFDPSSFTQPOETUPQSPUFDUJPODMBTT*BOENVTUPOMZCF
PQFSBUFEXJUIBQSPUFDUJWFFBSUIDPOOFDUJPO
"OBMMQPMFJTPMBUJOHTXJUDIXJUIBDPOUBDUHBQPGBUMFBTUNN
NVTU CF GJUUFE EVSJOH JOTUBMMBUJPO 5IJT NVTU SFNBJO BDDFTTJCMF BGUFS
JOTUBMMBUJPO
0OMZBRVBMJGJFEFMFDUSJDJBOXIPUBLFTUIFBQQSPQSJBUFSFHVMBUJPOT
JOUPBDDPVOUNBZMBZPSSFQMBDFUIFDPOOFDUJOHDBCMF
$SSOLDQFHZLWKRXWSRZHUFDEOH0OMZDPOOFDUJOBDDPSEBODF
XJUIUIFDPOOFDUJPOEJBHSBN*GOFDFTTBSZGJUUIFDPQQFSCSJEHF
TVQQMJFE
.BJOTQPXFSDBCMF)77'( TJOHMFQIBTFPS)77
'( UISFFQIBTFPSPOFXJUIBIJHIFSWBMVF0CTFSWFUIF
NJOJNVNDSPTTTFDUJPO5IFMFOHUIPGUIFDPOOFDUJOHDBCMFJTBU
MFBTU N
5IFZFMMPXHSFFOXJSFGPSUIFDPOEVDUPSDPOOFDUJPONVTUCF
NNMPOHFSUIBOUIFPUIFSXJSFTPOUIFBQQMJBODFTJEF
%POPULJOLPSUSBQUIFDPOOFDUJOHDBCMF
)LWWLQJWKHDSSOLDQFH
.BSL UIF DFOUSF PG UIF SFDFTT FYBDUMZ 'JU UIF TIPSU NPVOUJOH SBJM
UP UIF GSPOU PG UIF SFDFTT BOE UIF MPOH NPVOUJOH SBJM UP UIF SFBS PG
UIFSFDFTT.BLFTVSFUIFMVHTPGUIFNPVOUJOHSBJMTMJFPOUIF
XPSLUPQ5IFDFOUSFNBSLJOHPOUIFNPVOUJOHSBJMTNVTUCF
QSFDJTFMZGMVTIXJUIUIFDFOUSFNBSLJOHPGUIFSFDFTT
1RWH XIFOGJUUJOHUIFBQQMJBODFJOBTUPOFXPSLUPQHMVFPOUIF
NPVOUJOHSBJMTXJUIBUFNQFSBUVSFSFTJTUBOUUXPDPNQPOFOU
BEIFTJWF NFUBMPOTUPOF
-PXFSUIFBQQMJBODFJOUPUIFDVUPVU5IFTOBQJOQJOTPOUIF
BQQMJBODF NVTU MJF FYBDUMZ PO UIF DBUDI TQSJOHT 'JSNMZ QSFTT UIF
BQQMJBODFJOUPUIFDVUPVU 7KHSLQVRQWKHDSSOLDQFHPXVW
VQDSLQWRWKHFDWFKVSULQJV
5HPRYLQJWKHDSSOLDQFH
%JTDPOOFDUUIFBQQMJBODFGSPNUIFQPXFSTVQQMZ1VTIPVUUIF
BQQMJBODFGSPNCFMPX
&DXWLRQ
3JTLPGEBNBHF%POPUMFWFSPVUUIFBQQMJBODFGSPNBCPWF
fr
Þ
/PUJDFEFNPOUBHF
5HFRPPDQGDWLRQVLPSRUWDQWHV
-JSFBUUFOUJWFNFOUDFUUFOPUJDFFUMBDPOTFSWFSTPJHOFVTFNFOU
4FVMFNFOUFODBTEFODBTUSFNFOUDPSSFDUTFMPODFUUFOPUJDFEF
NPOUBHFMBT©DVSJU©FTUHBSBOUJFMPSTEFMVUJMJTBUJPO-FNPOUFVS
FTU SFTQPOTBCMF EV GPODUJPOOFNFOU DPSSFDU TVS MF MJFV P¹ MBQQBSFJM
FTUJOTUBMM©
4FVMVOTQ©DJBMJTUFBHS©©FTUIBCJMJU© SBDDPSEFSMBQQBSFJM
"WBOUUPVUUSBWBJMDPVQFSMBMJNFOUBUJPO©MFDUSJRVF
1PVS©WJUFSMFTCMFTTVSFTQBSDPVQVSFQPSUFSEFTHBOUTEF
QSPUFDUJPO-FTQJ¨DFTBDDFTTJCMFTQFOEBOUMFNPOUBHFQFVWFOU
BWPJSEFTBSªUFTWJWFT
1PVSMJOTUBMMBUJPOSFTQFDUFSMFTS¨HMFTFUOPSNFTFOWJHVFVSEBOT
MFEPNBJOFEFMBDPOTUSVDUJPOBJOTJRVFMFTJOTUSVDUJPOTEV
GPVSOJTTFVSMPDBME©MFDUSJDJU©
$FUBQQBSFJMGBJUQBSUJFEFMBDMBTTF JOTUBMMFSEBOTVONFVCMF
EFDVJTJOF*MGBVUMFQPTFSDPOGPSN©NFOUBVTDI©NB3FTQFDUFS
MBEJTUBODFNJOJNBMFFOUSFMBQQBSFJMFUMFTNVSTPVMFT©M©NFOUT
EFNFVCMFTVSMFTD´U©TBJOTJRVFWFSTMBSSJ¨SF
$FUBQQBSFJMOFTUQBTQS©WVQPVSMFGPODUJPOOFNFOUBWFDVOF
NJOVUFSJFFYUFSOFPVVOFDPNNBOEF EJTUBODFFYUFSOF
3UpSDUDWLRQGHVPHXEOHV
-FNFVCMFP¹FTUFODBTUS©MBQQBSFJMEPJUQPVWPJSS©TJTUFS VOF
UFNQ©SBUVSFEFp$-BTUBCJMJU©EVNFVCMFEPJUªUSFHBSBOUJF
BQS¨TMFTPQ©SBUJPOTEFE©DPVQF
3©BMJTFS MB E©DPVQF QPVS PV QMVTJFVST BQQBSFJMT 7BSJP EBOT MF QMBO
EFUSBWBJMTFMPOMFTDI©NBEFQPTF-BOHMFEVDIBOUEFDPVQF
EPJUªUSFEFpQBSSBQQPSUBVQMBOEFUSBWBJM
"QS¨T MFT PQ©SBUJPOT EF E©DPVQF ©MJNJOFS MFT DPQFBVY 4DFMMFS MFT
DIBOUTEFDPVQFBWFDVOQSPEVJUBTTVSBOUMFVSS©TJTUBODF MB
DIBMFVS
3FTQFDUFSVOFEJTUBODFNJOJNBMFEFNNFOUSFMFEFTTPVTEF
MBQQBSFJMFUMFT©M©NFOUTEVNFVCMF
-JOTUBMMBUJPOEPJUªUSFGBJUFEFNBOJ¨SF HBSBOUJSMBQSPUFDUJPO
DPOUSF MFT DPOUBDUT BDDJEFOUFMT 4J BQS¨T MB QPTF JM FTU QPTTJCMF EF
UPVDIFSMFEFTTPVTEFMBQQBSFJMJMGBVUJOTUBMMFSVOGPOE
JOUFSN©EJBJSFE©NPOUBCMFFYDMVTJWFNFOUBWFDVOPVUJM3FTQFDUFS
VOFEJTUBODFNJOJNBMFEFNNFOUSFMFGPOEJOUFSN©EJBJSFFUMF
EFTTPVTEFMBQQBSFJM
6LSOXVLHXUVDSSDUHLOV9DULRVRQWSRVpVHQVHPEOH UFOJS
DPNQUFEFMBQMBDFO©DFTTBJSFQPVSMBCBHVFUUFEFKPODUJPO
77 FOUSF MFT BQQBSFJMT -FT BQQBSFJMT QFVWFOU ©HBMFNFOU ªUSF
JOTUBMM©T EBOT EFT E©DPVQFT T©QBS©FT FO SFTQFDUBOU VOF EJTUBODF
NJOJNBMFEFNNFOUSFFVY
5DFFRUGHPHQWpOHFWULTXH
"WBOUEFSBDDPSEFSMBQQBSFJMW©SJGJF[MJOTUBMMBUJPOEPNFTUJRVF
7FJMMF[ VOFQSPUFDUJPOQBSGVTJCMFTVGGJTBOUFEFMJOTUBMMBUJPO
EPNFTUJRVF-BUFOTJPOFUMBGS©RVFODFEFMBQQBSFJMEPJWFOU
DP¯ODJEFSBWFDMJOTUBMMBUJPO©MFDUSJRVF WPJSQMBRVFTJHOBM©UJRVF
-BQQBSFJMFTUDPOGPSNF MBDMBTTFEFQSPUFDUJPO*FUEPJU
VOJRVFNFOUªUSFVUJMJT©BWFDVOFQSJTF DPOEVDUFVSEFQSPUFDUJPO
6OEJTKPODUFVSBHJTTBOUTVSUPVTMFTQ´MFTBWFDBVNPJOT NN
EPVWFSUVSFEFDPOUBDUEPJUªUSFJOU©HS© MJOTUBMMBUJPO$FEFSOJFS
EPJUFODPSFªUSFBDDFTTJCMFBQS¨TMFNPOUBHF
-BQPTFPVMFSFNQMBDFNFOUEVD¢CMFEFSBDDPSEFNFOUEPJU
VOJRVFNFOUªUSFS©BMJT© FQBSVO©MFDUSJDJFOTQ©DJBMJT©EBOTMF
SFTQFDUEFTQSFTDSJQUJPOTFOWJHVFVS
$SSDUHLOVDQVFkEOHGHUDFFRUGHPHQW SBDDPSEFNFOU
VOJRVFNFOU TFMPO MF TDI©NB EF SBDDPSEFNFOU "V CFTPJO NPOUF[
MFTQPOUTFODVJWSFGPVSOJT
$¢CMFEFSBDDPSEFNFOUBVTFDUFVS )77'(
NPOPQIBT©PV)77'( USJQIBT©PVEFQVJTTBODF
QMVT©MFW©F0CTFSWFSMBTFDUJPONJOJNBMF-POHVFVSEVD¢CMFEF
SBDDPSEFNFOUBVNPJOT N
$´U©BQQBSFJMMFCSJOKBVOFWFSUQPVSMFSBDDPSEFNFOUEV
DPOEVDUFVSEFQSPUFDUJPOEPJUªUSFEF NNQMVTMPOHRVFMFT
BVUSFTCSJOT
/FQBTQJODFSOJDPJODFSMFD¢CMFEFSBDDPSEFNFOU
